Showing posts with label Battle Royale. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Battle Royale. Show all posts

Wednesday, 21 March 2012

Three Movies that Should Be

Many movies nowadays are based off of other sources, like books, television shows, toys, and video games. It is safe to say that Hollywood won't run out of source material any time soon, but what should their next big production be? That's where I come in. This is a list of three movies that should be!

1: Portal (and Portal 2)
Directed by: Christopher Nolan
Starring: Mila Kunis, Ellen McLain, Stephen Merchant, J. K. Simmons

Christopher Nolan is really good at making movies that are out of the ordinary. Scratch that- he's just really good at making movies period. He's made great adaptations to previously famous materials before (Batman Begins, The Dark Knight) so there should be few issues in that department. And if you've ever played Portal, you know that is unlike any other mainstream game out there. It forces you to think- it is not a button masher like other first-person shooters. Creating a movie based on this games plays to all of Nolan's strengths as a director; just recall the mind-blowingness of Inception and you'll have an idea of how this movie would likely play out.

As for the actors, McLain, Simmons and Merchant were the voices of GLaDOS/Caroline, Cave Johnson, and Wheatley respectively. GLaDOS and Wheatley would probably be CGI, so keeping the same voice actors should be fine. As for Cave Johnson and Caroline, there could be some snippets of them together, and maybe (SPOILER) they could show some of Caroline's transformation into GLaDOS. J.K Simmons has acted on-screen in big-budget films already (Spiderman 1, 2, and 3), so it should be no problem for him. Finally, Mila Kunis has portrayed many different characters in her career, and she's portrayed them very well. Putting her in any role is a good idea, and the fact that she looks kind of like Chell is a bonus too.

Drawbacks: Chell doesn't speak. This was initially intended so that the player would be able to insert his or herself into the game, so it would be a more personal experience. Even Chell's name isn't mentioned at all in the game (I don't think.) So do we have her speak? Or does she remain silent?

Also, the cast is very small; at most it would be five or so people. The whole cast- if I remember correctly- was Chell and GLaDOS in the first game, and Wheatley, Cave Johnson, and Caroline joined them in the second game.

Finally, it would be really great if all of the original voice cast could be in this film, but Ellen McLain doesn't look like Caroline. Caroline is supposed to look like this:
A dark-haired lady in her late twenties/early thirties. Ellen McLain looks like this:
A fair-haired lady in her forties or so (I actually couldn't find her actual age.) 
I suppose another actress could replace her for the Caroline parts, but I feel like that would take away from the authenticity of the film.

REGARDLESS, this movie should be!

2: Battle Royale
Directed by: Quentin Tarantino
Starring: Original cast

Now, I know what you're thinking. Battle Royale has already been a film twice, and one of them was really good! It was all the gore and insanity of the original source material, so why remake something that was already a success to begin with?

I'll tell you why; friggin' Quentin Tarantino. I read Battle Royale when I was fourteen years old, and when I was fourteen I wasn't allowed to watch anything Tarantino. I'm sure if my parents had read Battle Royale before me, they wouldn't have let me read that either. But the first Tarantino film I watched was Kill Bill, which showed off his stylistic qualities as a director. There was a bit of dark humour, and tons of violence and blood and gore. But it went deeper than that. It wasn't just a revenge movie. It delved into the psyche of the assassin, and had developed characters. Battle Royale is similar in that regard.

After my review on Battle Royale and the Hunger Games, I provided an analysis of the story and character development and so on. I casually mentioned how great it would be if he directed Battle Royale, but after thinking it over for a bit, I really realized how well-suited Tarantino would actually be. He had already worked with one of the original cast members of the 2000 version already, Chiaki Kuriyama (Go Go Yubari in Kill Bill, Chigusa in Battle Royale), so why not make the movie?

Drawbacks: Really, the only major drawback I see here is the fact that the movie has already been made. Tarantino has the basic outline for his movie already; he doesn't necessarily have to use all the same elements from the movie either. It would be all the gore and violence and foulness that was Battle Royale, with added style and a new interpretation.

But, I guess it boils down to repetitiveness. There has already been a movie, it did well, why reboot it so soon? *cough*Spiderman*cough*

REGARDLESS, this movie should be!

3: The Legend of Zelda
Directed by: Peter Jackson
Starring: David Kross, Willem Dafoe, Carey Mulligan, Dakota Goyo(?), Joey King(?)

This one doesn't even need explanation. You KNOW it would be amazing.
... but I will explain anyway.

It's an action-packed epic fantasy adventure with a vast landscape and a host of interesting characters. And there's a massive volcano as one of the plot points. Where have I seen that formula before? Long story short, if any director can take a well-known and loved game and turn it into a beautiful, action-y movie, it would be Jackson.

Also, I recall a few years ago, IGN released a trailer for a Legend of Zelda movie. There was huge excitement for this film even though the quality of the animation was sub-par, the costumes looked off, and te acting was very "meh." At least in my honest opinion. If this movie were to be made, I have no doubt in my mind that it would not only be outrageously awesome, but pretty successful too. I mean, LORD OF THE RINGS MEETS LEGEND OF ZELDA?! OH MY GOD I WOULD WET MYSELF WITH EXCITEMENT IN PERPETUAL FLOW UNTIL I EVENTUALLY DIED OF DEHYDRATION.

But I digress.

David Kross would probably make a really good Link I think. He's 22 years old, but still has a baby-face. He's an up-and-coming actor from Germany who hasn't been in too many movies to date, but he has done an excellent job in the one's he has been in (The Reader, Knallhart.) His younger counterpart, if he were to be included, would be Dakota Goyo, who has been praised as a natural actor with great emotional range.

Carey Mulligan, what can I say. Her subtleties as an actress are great, and subtleties are what can make or break a performance. She would be best suited (in my opinion) for the role of Zelda, and maybe also Sheik, but there is a bit of confusion regarding Sheik's gender (I will go in depth in the drawbacks section.) Her younger counterpart would be Joey King, who, despite her age, has been in many movies to date (not to mention, she's been cast as a minor character in The Dark Knight Rises, so automatic plus there.)

Willem Dafoe. Need I say more? He's a great villain. Even in Spiderman, he had some great moments (although they were few and far between, but hey, everyone has a bad performance once in a while.) I think he could pull off  the evil Gerudo King Ganon/Ganondorf very well. And his voice is just so dark and deep and intimidating! It would be a bit of work to get him to look the part, but it can be done.

Drawbacks: There are many. The game is about adventure and figuring out how to navigate your way through numerous temples and solving puzzles to get necessary items. The story is a very rinse, wash, and repeat save-the-princess formula.

And will they base the movie on the entire Zelda universe, or base it off one single game? My personal preference would be to base it off one game (Ocarina of Time), but then would that warrant a movie version of each game?

Will they go into each temple? That would make it a very long and repetitive movie, but they could split it into two films perhaps. If they were to base it off Ocarina of Time, they could split the movie up so the first one would be centred on young Link, and the second would be based off old Link.

Or will they scrap that idea completely like they did with the April Fools Day trailer and have adult Link throughout the movie?

Also, the protagonist Link is well known for never speaking. Should that be maintained in the movie? Is Link going to just be stoic and quiet (aside from the occasional "HYAA")? Would they give him dialogue?

And then there's the whole controversy with Sheik; is Sheik man-Zelda, or is Sheik just Zelda in drag? There is evidence for both theories. I can't go into detail on this controversy or else this already long post will be much longer. Here is where you can find a neat summary of the controversy. Read it!
So, should a man be cast as Sheik? Should Mulligan just be dressed in drag? Decisions, decisions!

Finally... Dammit, Navi was an annoying piece of work, eh?!

REGARDLESS, this movie should be!

Tuesday, 13 March 2012

Hunger Games and Battle Royale

With the Hunger Games movie coming out in just over a week, I thought I'd jump the band wagon and give her a go. And by "giver her a go", I mean do a contrast/comparison bit on the Hunger Games and Battle Royale (just the books, not the movies.) Also, please bear with me, as it has been about five or six years since I read Battle Royale, and I may not get some plot points quite right, but I shall try my best.

Introductions!


Battle Royale is a stand-alone work written by Japanese author Houshun Takami in 1999. It takes place in an alternate version of Japan called The Republic of Greater East Asia, a totalitarian state that each forces one class of junior high school students to fight to the death.

There are a number of measures taken to ensure that the students fight. First, they are outfitted with explosive collars (remember this because this is important). Then, they each select one bag containing a weapon, a map, maybe some other stuff, I don't really remember (the map is important too!) The weapons provided range from machine guns to hatchets to poison and I think someone may have gotten a spoon.

Now, the explosive collars ensure a few rules. If no student is killed in 24 hours, all of the collars explode and there is no winner. Certain areas of the location become off-limits, and anyone who wanders into an off-limits area or happens to be there when it becomes off-limits, the collar explodes. If a student tries to remove his or her collar, it explodes. If a student tries to escape, his or her collar explodes.

The map is necessary to provide the layout of the location (in this case, an island) along with a grid that represents the "areas." Of course, one by one these areas become off-limits, so don't lose your map.

The Hunger Games is the first in a trilogy by Suzanne Collins. If you don't know the plot of The Hunger Games, you are an anomaly. Congratulations! For the anomalies and the misinformed, Hunger Games takes place in a futuristic North America called Panem and it is also a totalitarian state. Panem is split up into twelve (formerly thirteen, but we won't get into that) districts ruled by the Capitol. There had been an ineffective rebellion against the Capitol years ago, and after it was taken care of, someone had somehow figured out the secret to preventing future rebellions; forcing 24 children to fight to the death until only one survivor remains. This televised fight to the death is called the Hunger Games.

One boy and one girl from each district between the ages of twelve and eighteen, called Tributes, are chosen at random to fight to the death in an arena. Volunteers are allowed, and are common in the richer districts where competing in the Hunger Games is considered honourable. For every other district, being chosen as a Tribute is practically a death sentence.



Once the Tributes are selected, they are sent to the Capitol for two weeks to train, to be assessed, and to be interviewed on television. This is crucial because Tributes are allowed to get parcels from sponsors during the games, and this time is used to attract them. Sponsors could be betting on the tributes or they could be members of the Tribute's district trying to help them out. The parcels could contain anything from food to medicine, and are sent to the Tributes via parachute.

At the beginning of the game, the Tributes are provided with weapons and other accessories like blankets and pots for cooking (the games could last weeks, so cooking is a necessary skill.) However, these items are acquired dodgeball-style in a 3-2-1 GO chase. Only instead of chancing getting hit with a ball in the face, you chance getting hit with death to the face.



There are people overseeing the games, and they can control the arena's climate, weather, and can cause fireballs to shoot out from the ground if things get too dull.

Similarities


There are many striking similarities in both Battle Royale and Hunger Games. They're both about children killing each other, they're both set in a totalitarian setting, and they both have a main theme of rebellion because (*spoiler alert*) they both cheat the system and there is more than one winner. If you were to write a three-sentence summary of both books, they might be identical.

So, if the Hunger Games is so similar to Battle Royale, is it a blatant rip-off?

No. Here's why.

Differences


The intended audience is different. I was sitting on the train on my way home and there was a boy sitting across from me- he couldn't have been older than ten- reading the Hunger Games. When I got home, my forty-nine year old mother had just finished reading it and loved it. It's graphic, but not so graphic that it would  warrant a criticism by my mother.

Battle Royale, on the other hand, has a much smaller audience. It is graphic, it is gory, it explores other mature themes (aside from- you know- children killing each other), and is it ever foul-mouthed.

Battle Royale is like a Quentin Tarantino film, and the Hunger Games is like a good Steven Spielburg film- stylistically speaking. Both are great, both cover mature themes, but while my mother would enjoy a Spielburg film like, say, Saving Private Ryan, she would not watch Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs. It's all in the way they handle the gore and how the content is handled.
... Also, if Tarantino directed an adaptation of Battle Royale, that would be amazing. Kill Bill style Battle Royale? I would be all over that.

Another striking difference is the narrative and character development. The Hunger Games has a few really well developed characters, and the rest are not very developed. In Battle Royale, most of the characters are developed to the point where I actually cared when they died. In the Hunger Games, I only really cared when one Tribute died. The rest were just "meh," because I didn't get to know them. I understand that the perspective that Collins wrote in made it impossible to get into the character of anyone that the protagonist, Katniss, didn't know on an intimate level, but I wanted to feel bad when the Tributes died. That's the main problem with writing in the first person- you can only become invested in a few characters. In Battle Royale, I felt bad when even the antagonist died because he had a backstory. Battle Royale was written in the 3rd person perspective, and follows many different characters throughout the story. I was emotionally invested in many characters, and I knew they would die, but I had hoped they would live anyway.

I should take this opportunity to say that I have no qualms with either book. In fact, it's just the opposite. I really enjoyed both! If you ask me which one I prefer, I don't know which one I would chose. In conclusion, I guess you could say that the themes and plot are very similar, and I guess you could argue that one is a rip-off of the other. But I would have to disagree.

... and one last note, did Katniss not remind anyone of Susan from The Chronicles of Narnia (especially the fourth book, Prince Caspian)? She was a teenager with long dark hair that was often braided and was a great archer who shot an apple from far away to prove her skills. That's about as far as the similarities go, but still.

Honourable Mentions


The Running Man, The Lord of the Flies, The Condemned (don't watch. It sucks)